The Voice of Demand

Archive for February, 2009

Studeo

Know When to Create a Category

February 27th, 2009 - By Anthony

As an agency, we’re often presented with products that are looking for help in finding their voice.   There are several ways this may show itself:

  1. It may come across as another ‘me too’ product, or
  2. It tries to fight the incumbents on pre-established terms and ground rules, or
  3. It thinks it is the answer for everyone, or
  4. It doesn’t clearly know where it fits.

Most of the time a brand can work within an existing category through positioning and appropriate messaging.  Because consumers prefer some choice there’s almost always room for a strong number 2 or 3.

But sometimes the product appears to be something new and different - deserving of the chance to create a category all its own.   But what are the elements that drive a successful category?   How can we identify a potential category-creator?   There are three elements we look for:  Ideas, Insights and Innovation.

  • Idea:  The product is new or different; it defies easy comparison to established brands.  “It’s close to ____ but not really.”   It does something different than what we would expect for the category, e.g. Curves or Online Law Schools.
  • Insight: The difference has real value to a group of people.   And this group isn’t likely who we thought at first.  “You know who really needs this, its __________”.   The ah ha moment where the right audience becomes clear; e.g. ‘law school is not just for lawyers’.
  • Innovation: The functionality, delivery mechanism and business model have to be different; or at least 2 out of 3.  If not, the 800# gorilla will make their category bigger by swallowing the product up.   It must be painful for incumbents to compete.

These three elements often present a challenge to established brands and companies.   New companies are much better suited to find their niche; although they may be challenged to execute.   Established brands can execute but their legacy retards change.

Studeo

Lumenas Studios is currently producing a movie called The Legend of Santa Claus that is set to be released in November of 2010.  At first one might ask, “Do we need another movie about Santa?”  At least that was the reaction of some of the bloggers who read the latest Press Release announcing the movie.  Going into this we knew that even marketing a movie about a character as loveable and well known as Santa would have its challenges.

Lumenas is a new client of ours and two days ago I had the opportunity to tour their studio in downtown Salt Lake City where they are hard at work.  We will be managing all internet marketing and web development relating to the movie over the next two years.

The Legend of Santa Claus is a full length animated adventure film about the story of Santa’s youth.  There have been many movies about Santa leaving the North Pole to deliver toys to good little girls and boys but never one about what Santa was like as a kid.  So yes, this is a story about Santa but no, it’s not one you have heard before.

And therein lies the challenge in marketing this movie.  Leveraging the icon of the magical man in the red suit and white beard enough to get people interested in the movie, without making them wonder why we need another movie about Santa.

But after touring the studio and seeing the dedicated people hard at work, each working in their field of expertise, I can see why we need another movie about Santa and why this won’t be like anything we have seen before.  The atmosphere is one of creativity and energy and everyone involved, including me, is excited to be working on this project.  I saw people painting, sculpting, animating, drawing, creating, lighting and doing what they do best, make good movies.

Over the next two years we hope to be able to give people a glimpse into the world that we saw two days ago and do our part to tell the story of the young boy who grew up to be the man in the red suit.

Studeo

Sometimes having a great product isn’t enough to get people talking.  As we can see from Tourism Queensland, sometimes you just need to give people something to talk about.

So what is everyone talking about?  Only the best job in the world.  Don’t believe me, here is a paragraph from the job description.

“Tourism Queensland is seeking applicants for the best job in the world! The role of Island
Caretaker is a six-month contract, based on luxurious Hamilton Island in the Great Barrier
Reef. It’s a live-in position with flexible working hours and key responsibilities include
exploring the islands of the Great Barrier Reef to discover what the area has to offer.
You’ll be required to report back on your adventures to Tourism Queensland
headquarters in Brisbane (and the rest of the world) via weekly blogs, photo diary, video
updates and ongoing media interviews. On offer is a unique opportunity to help promote
the wondrous Islands of the Great Barrier Reef.”  You can read the full description here.

And did I mention that the job requires 12 hours of work a month and pays approximatley $100k US for the six month contract?

By giving people something to talk about, Tourism Queensland has:

  • Received over 35,000 applications
  • Generated hundreds of user generated videos on Youtube
  • Generated thousands of blog mentions in many different languages
  • Received tons of media coverage
  • Generated lots of talk on Twitter
  • Inspired many Facebook groups

Don’t just hope people will talk about your product.  Give them something to talk about.

Studeo

Social Media and Marketing

February 19th, 2009 - By Anthony

To help marketers develop strategies for using social media we posted a presentation as news release.  The outline works through the intersection of marketing and social media as a series of discussion points.

To make it interesting, it is completely designed as 50 tweets.   All 50 points made in less than 140 characters, in case you want to forward them on.

Studeo

The Pareto Principle states that, for many events, roughly 80% of the effects come from 20% of the causes. This is better known as the 80/20 rule. Applying this to social networking membership, you soon realize you are among a sea of inactive users just taking up server space. According to Facebook, the site has more than 175 million active users. They define “active user” as someone who has logged in to their account more than once in thirty days. –hardly active…

Anyway, the goal is to explore the personalities of these active users. We can easily examine these under three distinct behaviors and approximate their size with the 80/20 rule:

· Networkateers (9%): members who provide original content and interact with others

· King Cobras (11%): members who only comment on other’s content

· Fort Knoxians (80%): members who do not interact with others nor provide original content

Networkateers: Simply defined as the movers and shakers of the social networking world–people not afraid to air their laundry (sometimes dirty) and typically share opinions on a broad range of topics–the users posting links to videos, funny articles, or personal blogs. The same people not afraid to tweet, tweet, and retweet. The nine percent estimate is based on Facebook’s percentage of users who change their status message within a 24-hour period—which is one of the most basic functions of the website.

King Cobras: Not meant to be negative, but an accurate term to illustrate the behavior of this type of user. Much like a King Cobra that waits patiently, almost motionless before striking its prey, these social networking personalities only comment on others content. Usually, making calculated and overly cautious comments on others pictures, posts, and status updates. It’s safe to say, these users are worried that their online content could hurt them with future endeavors (jobs, relationships, etc.). In the blogosphere, these users largely go by aliases or stay anonymous.

Fort Knoxians: With the growing awareness of identity theft and internet scams, more and more people are just along for the social networking ride. Simply being a member grants access to friends’ pages and gives the individual user a window to their network, but they are reluctant to share any personal information or interact with other users—waiting for the day they can tell their friends “I told you so!” for over-sharing online.

Personalities are usually defined by the leading attribute (Myers-Briggs or Big Five) of extroversion or introversion. In the social networking space, extroverts could easily be a Fort Knoxian and an introvert could live a more social life (or a Second Life) as a Networkateer.

Facebook touts that the average user has 120 friends; or better explained, the average user knows only 10 people that actually post their own content and regularly interacts with others.

………no offense to Fort Knox Army Base or King Cobras!

Studeo

Changes in Journalism

February 16th, 2009 - By Anthony

The lines between various aspects of journalism continue to blur and create new categories.

  • Social media meets the press release.   First, no longer are press releases written for the press; they’re written for everyone  - clients, consumers, and investors.   A good release strategy helps with search.   Second, the Internet is consumed differently than print.   We do not read, we scan.   A 2 page release in 5 paragraphs just doesn’t work any more.  Third, words are only one way of communicating.  Places to check out for the social media newsroom include.

  • Para Journalism is also emerging in a new direction.
    • Spot.US - a marketplace where citizens, journalists, and news organizations can come together.   Ideas for stories are posted and funded via micro-contributions.  Highly California (bay area) centric; but interesting to peruse.
    • newsassignment - a crowdsourcing approach to open-source journalism.   Several projects looking at the intersection of professionals and journalists.
    • Citizen Marketers - Ben McConnell and Jackie Huba’s book on the topic.
Studeo

Good agencies employ great storytellers. Good stories capture attention, build trust and credibility, and often evoke an emotional response, all worthy goals of any marketing communication. In Seth Godin’s book, All Marketers are Liars, he adds credence to this argument in suggesting that effective marketers don’t talk about features and benefits, but rather they tell compelling stories — stories people want to believe.

Good storytellers develop a deep, rehearsed understanding of the key elements to be masterfully woven together and delivered in engaging fashion. Good marketers immerse themselves in the products and services offered by their clients. This intimate understanding teaches the skilled marketer the key messages she will use in communicating the client’s story. The master storyteller knows well  her audience. This knowledge is used to shape and cater the story. While speaking from a common platform, the storyteller is adept at catering and delivering her message in terms with which the audience can easily and personally relate.

During this past presidential campaign this concept was on display almost daily. Famously, Joe the Plumber became the hero of John McCain’s story to America. The candidates shaped their stories to appeal to diverse groups such as unions, corporate executives, coal miners, and even Hollywood, while the platform or underlying message remained largely intact. To a citizenry feeling unprecedented concern about their future, a simple story of change was compelling enough to make history in this country.

When the master storyteller delivers the right story to the right audience, the results are often powerful and memorable.

 So, savvy marketer, tell stories about the impact going back to school will have on the lives of those that do. Tell stories about protecting those you love most with a security system. Tell stories about the sheer joy and escape of spending Saturday afternoons on the lake in a new boat. Hey, it may not be Moby Dick, but told well these stories will generate a whale (sorry, I had to) of a response.

One final note about storytelling. A wise mentor once taught me that good advertising is often about telling only half of the story. You tell the whole story upfront and you’ve taken away my incentive to ask “what comes next” and then follow up to find out (the coveted response part of advertising). The half told tale is the tool of the master storyteller.

Studeo

Salt Lake is Fit for Purpose

February 11th, 2009 - By Jack

logo_masthead

Salt Lake City was just named “Fittest City in the United States” by Men’s Health magazine. Besides the obvious explanation that a representative from Men’s Health magazine must have seen me hard at work in the gym, I can’t help but wonder if Salt Lake City is being led by example.

Located just north of Salt Lake City is one of Studeo’s prized clients; ICON Health & Fitness. ICON is the world’s largest developer, manufacturer and marketer of fitness equipment with brands like Nordic Track, Pro-Form, Weider, Reebok and Gold’s Gym. However, ICON’s dedication does not solely rest in their manufacturing but also in their dedication to the local community.

The mission statement for ICON Health and Fitness is “Changing lives with fitness innovation.” Locally, ICON delivers on this mission with generous donations stretching from treadmills to strength equipment, all in an attempt to make the state more fit.

If ICON Health & Fitness is doing their part and seeing a direct correlation to the health and wellness of Salt Lake City, what can we do in the advertising world to better the community in which we do business?

ICON is a beautiful depiction of a company who truly leads by example and also enjoys “success” - on the side.

Studeo

Last Ad Standing

February 10th, 2009 - By Anthony

In the cowboy movies, the last gunslinger standing rides off into the sunset with the girl.  In online advertising its often the same; the last ad shown gets credit for the conversion.

In a recent iMedia article on ROI Young-Bean Song from Atlas pokes some worthy holes in that simplistic view of the world.  I want to extend the argument to include all media.   We know TV affects search and radio affects mobile.   A full attribution model would look at the entire integrated media plan.

Studeo

Truth in Advertising

February 10th, 2009 - By Anthony

I know customers appreciate it when we develop campaigns that reflect how they perceive the world, not how we or our clients would like them to.

On the radio this morning I heard a radio spot for a local restaurant (The Mayan) that started with:  The food here “sucks” - yes they used s-word.    The spot went on to say that while they had great ambiance and quick service the food didn’t live up to expectations.  So they fired the chef.  Yes, they said that too.

Since perceptions are a very hard thing to change this spot goes right to the heart of the matter:  “The reason you stopped coming is because we failed to deliver on our promise. In fact we sucked.”   In essence they said we heard you (listening is good) and we’re changing.

Too bad they didn’t take this all the way to the website - it contains standard restaurant fare including a PDF of the menu.   They should have started a contest - tell us which items suck and why you’d get rid of it.   That would have been a completely integrated campaign.

We’ll need to check back in a bit and see how its changed.